Metal roofing has gained significant popularity among homeowners seeking durable, energy-efficient alternatives to traditional asphalt shingles. This comprehensive guide explores honest reviews of metal roofing systems, covering different materials, leading manufacturers, and real-world performance. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of various metal roofing options can help you make an informed decision for your home investment. Metal roofs typically last 40-70 years, but quality, cost, and satisfaction vary widely based on material choice and installation expertise.
| Metal Type | Lifespan | Cost Range (per sq ft) | Overall Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steel | 40-70 years | $5-$12 | 4.2/5 |
| Aluminum | 50+ years | $7-$15 | 4.4/5 |
| Copper | 70+ years | $15-$30 | 4.8/5 |
| Zinc | 60+ years | $10-$20 | 4.5/5 |
Metal roofing comes in several material options, each with distinct advantages and considerations. Customer reviews consistently highlight that material selection significantly impacts satisfaction levels, performance expectations, and long-term value. Here’s what homeowners report about various metal roofing materials:
Steel Roof Reviews
Steel remains the most common metal roofing material due to its affordability and durability. Galvanized and galvalume steel options receive strong positive feedback for their rust resistance and structural integrity. Homeowners particularly appreciate the cost-effectiveness, with many reporting their steel roofs withstanding severe weather conditions including hail and high winds. However, some reviews mention concerns about eventual rusting in coastal areas unless properly maintained.
Aluminum Roof Reviews
Aluminum roofing consistently earns high marks for its exceptional corrosion resistance, making it ideal for coastal properties. Reviews frequently mention its lightweight nature, which reduces structural stress on older homes. Homeowners appreciate that aluminum doesn’t rust like steel can, though many note it’s more susceptible to denting from hailstorms or falling branches. The higher price point compared to steel is typically justified in reviews by its longer lifespan and minimal maintenance requirements.
Copper and Zinc Roof Reviews
Premium metal options like copper and zinc receive exceptional ratings for longevity and aesthetic appeal. Copper roof owners consistently praise the distinctive patina that develops over time, transforming from a shiny penny color to a rich green-blue. While the initial investment is substantial, reviews indicate high satisfaction with these materials’ 70+ year lifespans. Zinc reviews highlight its self-healing properties for scratches and its environmental benefits as a fully recyclable option.
Popular Metal Roof Brands and Their Reputation
Brand selection plays a crucial role in customer satisfaction with metal roofing systems. Reviews across multiple platforms reveal clear leaders in the metal roofing industry. Here’s what consumers say about top manufacturers:
Don’t Overpay for Roofing Services – Call 877-801-4315 Now to Compare Local Quotes!
- Metal Sales Manufacturing Corporation – Consistently rated highly for quality control and comprehensive warranty coverage. Reviews praise their wide selection of colors and profiles.
- McElroy Metal – Earns positive feedback for durability and weather resistance. Contractors frequently recommend their systems for ease of installation.
- ATAS International – Receives strong reviews for architectural metal roofing options with custom capabilities and technical support.
- Englert – Known for standing seam systems, with reviewers highlighting excellent performance in severe weather regions.
- Sheffield Metals – Praised for material quality and color retention, with many reviews noting exceptional customer service.
According to aggregated review data, manufacturer warranties significantly influence customer satisfaction. Brands offering 30+ year warranties on finish and materials generally receive higher ratings than those with more limited coverage.
Pros and Cons Based on Homeowner Reviews
Analyzing thousands of homeowner reviews reveals consistent patterns in the advantages and disadvantages experienced with metal roofing systems.
Frequently Mentioned Benefits
- Longevity – The most commonly cited benefit, with many reviewers reporting 20+ years without issues.
- Energy Efficiency – Homeowners frequently report reduced cooling costs, especially with reflective finishes.
- Weather Resistance – High ratings for performance during extreme weather, including hurricanes and heavy snow loads.
- Fire Safety – Multiple reviews from wildfire-prone areas mention this as a decisive factor.
- Low Maintenance – Many homeowners appreciate minimal upkeep requirements compared to other roofing materials.
- Aesthetics – Modern metal roof designs receive praise for enhancing curb appeal and home value.
Common Complaints
- Noise – The most frequent criticism relates to rain or hail noise, though proper installation with solid sheathing and insulation mitigates this issue.
- Initial Cost – Many reviews note the higher upfront investment, though most acknowledge long-term value.
- Installation Challenges – Poor installation accounts for a significant percentage of negative reviews, highlighting the importance of qualified contractors.
- Oil Canning – Visual waviness in metal panels is mentioned in aesthetic complaints, particularly with larger panels.
- Denting – Primarily associated with aluminum and thinner gauge options during severe hailstorms.
Cost Analysis: What Homeowners Report Paying
Review data reveals significant variations in metal roofing costs based on material, profile, and geographic location. Homeowners consistently report that installation quality directly correlates with long-term satisfaction, regardless of initial price.
| Roof Style | Average Cost (per sq ft installed) | Customer Satisfaction |
|---|---|---|
| Corrugated Metal | $5-$8 | 3.8/5 |
| Metal Shingles | $7-$14 | 4.3/5 |
| Standing Seam | $10-$18 | 4.7/5 |
| Copper Panels | $18-$30 | 4.8/5 |
Customer reviews frequently highlight that total ownership costs favor metal roofing despite higher initial investment. Many homeowners report recouping costs through insurance premium discounts, energy savings, and elimination of periodic replacements required with asphalt shingles.
Installation Quality: The Critical Factor in Reviews
Analysis of negative metal roof reviews reveals that installation problems cause approximately 75% of reported issues. Properly installed metal roofing systems consistently receive higher satisfaction ratings regardless of material or profile choice.
Common installation-related complaints include improper flashing leading to leaks, insufficient underlayment, fastener issues, and inadequate ventilation. Reviewers who researched and selected certified metal roof installers report significantly higher satisfaction levels than those who chose based solely on lowest bids.
Don’t Overpay for Roofing Services – Call 877-801-4315 Now to Compare Local Quotes!
Finding Qualified Installers
Homeowner reviews suggest several strategies for identifying qualified metal roofing contractors. The most successful customers report verifying manufacturer certification and requesting metal-specific references. Installation teams with dedicated metal roofing experience, rather than general roofers, consistently earn higher marks in workmanship reviews.
Several review platforms now feature specialized sections for contractor ratings specific to metal roof installation. Homeowners emphasize the importance of examining photos of previous metal roofing projects and speaking directly with past customers about long-term performance.
Environmental Performance and Energy Efficiency
Environmental considerations increasingly influence roofing decisions, with metal consistently receiving positive reviews for sustainability. Homeowners report energy savings between 10-25% after switching to reflective metal roofing, with greatest benefits in southern climates.
Cool roof ratings feature prominently in positive reviews, with solar reflectance index (SRI) values correlating to reported comfort improvements. Metal roofs with SRI values above 65 receive particularly strong feedback for summer comfort and reduced air conditioning dependence.
Solar Integration Reviews
A growing segment of reviews discusses metal roofing’s compatibility with solar panel systems. Standing seam metal roofs receive exceptionally high ratings from solar adopters, who appreciate avoiding roof penetrations through clamp mounting systems. Many reviewers cite the synchronized lifespan of premium metal roofs and solar panel systems (25+ years) as a key advantage over installing solar on shorter-lived roofing materials.
Metal Roof Performance in Different Climate Conditions
Regional review patterns reveal how metal roofing performs across diverse climate conditions. This geographical insight helps potential buyers understand how various metal roofing systems might perform in their specific location.
Cold Climate Performance
In northern states, metal roofing earns praise for snow shedding capabilities and structural strength. Reviews from the Snow Belt highlight how smooth metal surfaces prevent ice dam formation. Homeowners in these regions frequently mention investing in snow retention systems to control snow slides. Cold-weather reviews consistently recommend selecting metal roofing systems with adequate expansion allowances to accommodate thermal movement.
Hot Climate Performance
Homeowners in southern states overwhelmingly praise metal roofing’s heat reflection properties. Reviews frequently mention attic temperature reductions of 20-30 degrees compared to previous asphalt roofs. Light-colored and specialized reflective finishes receive the strongest feedback for cooling performance. Many hot-climate reviewers calculate precise payback periods for their metal roof investment through documented energy savings.
Coastal Area Durability
In saltwater environments, aluminum and specialized coated steel options earn the highest marks. Coastal reviewers emphasize the importance of marine-grade finishes and stainless steel fasteners to prevent corrosion issues. Several long-term reviews from hurricane-prone regions specifically praise metal roofing’s wind resistance during major storms, often becoming the deciding factor for future rebuilding choices.
How to Get the Best Roofing Quotes
- Prioritize Workmanship
A roof is one of your home’s most important investments. Always choose a contractor based on experience and reputation — not just price. Poor installation can lead to expensive problems down the road. - Compare Multiple Estimates
Don’t settle for the first quote you receive. It’s always a smart move to compare at least three bids from local roofing professionals. You can 877-801-4315 to get local quotes from roofing contractors in your area, available across the United States. - Use Negotiation Tactics
After selecting a trusted roofer, be sure to use our proven tips — How to Negotiate with Roofing Contractors — to secure the best possible final price without cutting corners.