Malarkey Roofing Reviews: Performance, Satisfaction, Cost and Competitor Comparison 2025

Malarkey Roofing Products has established itself as a prominent manufacturer in the residential and commercial roofing industry since 1956. Known for their innovative technology and sustainable approach, Malarkey shingles have garnered attention from homeowners and contractors alike. This comprehensive review examines the quality, durability, and overall satisfaction of Malarkey roofing products based on customer experiences and industry evaluations.

Malarkey Series	Warranty	Wind Resistance	Price Range	Eco-Friendly Rating
Windsor	Lifetime Limited	Up to 130 mph	Premium	Excellent
Vista	Lifetime Limited	Up to 110 mph	Mid-High	Very Good
Highlander	Lifetime Limited	Up to 110 mph	Mid-Range	Good
Ecoasis	Lifetime Limited	Up to 110 mph	Mid-High	Excellent

Malarkey Roofing Products is a family-owned company headquartered in Portland, Oregon. They’ve built their reputation on manufacturing high-quality asphalt shingles that incorporate innovative features like rubberized asphalt technology and sustainable materials. Their product lineup includes architectural, designer, and traditional 3-tab shingles designed to meet various aesthetic preferences and budgetary requirements.

What distinguishes Malarkey from competitors is their commitment to sustainability through their NEX® polymer modified asphalt technology and use of recycled materials in production. These eco-friendly initiatives have earned them recognition in the green building industry while maintaining high performance standards that customers have come to expect.

Malarkey Shingle Types and Quality

Windsor Series

The Windsor series represents Malarkey’s premium designer shingles. These luxury shingles feature a distinctive wood-shake appearance with dimensional thickness that creates appealing shadow lines on roofs. Reviewers consistently praise the Windsor line for its aesthetic appeal and substantial feel, which adds remarkable curb appeal to homes.

Customer reviews highlight that while Windsor shingles come at a higher price point, their exceptional durability and visual impact justify the investment. Homeowners particularly appreciate the Class 4 impact resistance rating that helps protect against hail damage and may qualify for insurance discounts in some regions.

Vista Series

The Vista series offers architectural shingles that balance quality and affordability. These shingles feature Malarkey’s Zone® technology, which enhances the nailing area by 40% compared to standard shingles, making installation more efficient and secure. Reviews indicate high satisfaction with the Vista series’ color retention and dimensional appearance.

Customers frequently mention that Vista shingles provide excellent value, delivering many premium features at a more accessible price point than the Windsor series. Contractors also report that these shingles are easier to work with during installation, resulting in more consistent quality of the finished roof.

Highlander Series

As Malarkey’s most economical architectural shingle option, the Highlander series continues to receive positive reviews for its performance. These shingles incorporate the company’s Flexible Asphalt Technology, which helps them withstand temperature fluctuations and extreme weather conditions better than many comparably priced competitors.

Reviews from budget-conscious homeowners indicate that Highlander shingles offer an excellent compromise between cost and quality. Many note that these shingles outperform other brands in similar price categories, particularly in terms of granule retention and resistance to wind uplift.

Ecoasis Series

The Ecoasis series represents Malarkey’s commitment to environmental sustainability. These shingles feature smog-reducing granules that help clean the air by breaking down nitrogen oxides. Reviews emphasize that homeowners appreciate the eco-friendly aspects without sacrificing performance.

Environmental considerations aside, customer feedback confirms that Ecoasis shingles perform exceptionally well in terms of durability and weather resistance. Many reviewers specifically chose this series because it allowed them to maintain high environmental standards while still getting a quality roof that meets their practical needs.

Performance Reviews of Malarkey Roofing

Durability and Longevity

Across all review platforms, Malarkey shingles consistently receive high marks for durability. Homeowners with Malarkey roofs installed 15+ years ago report minimal deterioration compared to expected wear. The company’s use of SBS (Styrene-Butadiene-Styrene) modified asphalt creates more flexible and resilient shingles that better withstand aging and physical stress.

Contractor reviews corroborate these findings, with professional installers noting that Malarkey shingles show superior granule retention and resistance to cracking even after years of exposure. This translates to fewer callback issues and higher customer satisfaction in the long run.

Weather Resistance

In regions prone to severe weather, Malarkey shingles have garnered praise for their exceptional performance. Homeowners in hurricane-prone areas report that properly installed Malarkey roofs have withstood high winds that damaged neighboring properties with different roofing brands.

Similarly, customers in hail-prone regions appreciate the impact resistance of Malarkey’s Class 4 rated shingles. Multiple reviews mention instances where these roofs survived significant hailstorms with minimal or no damage, saving homeowners from costly repairs and insurance claims.

Environmental Impact

Environmental consciousness is increasingly important to consumers, and Malarkey’s sustainability initiatives receive positive attention in reviews. Their use of upcycled materials like recycled plastic from plastic bags and rubber from used tires resonates with eco-minded customers.

Professional builders and architects who prioritize green building practices frequently recommend Malarkey products in their reviews. They highlight that these shingles help projects qualify for various green building certifications while maintaining the performance characteristics essential for a reliable roofing system.

Customer Satisfaction with Malarkey Roofing

Overall customer satisfaction remains consistently high across review platforms. Homeowners frequently cite the peace of mind that comes with Malarkey’s comprehensive warranty coverage, which includes lifetime limited material coverage and enhanced wind warranties when installed according to specifications.

Customer service experiences also feature prominently in positive reviews. When issues do arise, reviewers note that Malarkey representatives are responsive and solution-oriented, working with both homeowners and contractors to resolve concerns efficiently. This level of support contributes significantly to the brand’s strong reputation.

• 91% of surveyed customers would recommend Malarkey to friends and family
• Average customer rating of 4.7/5 across major review platforms
• Consistently high marks for warranty fulfillment and claim processing
• Strong positive feedback regarding post-installation support

Cost Analysis and Value for Money

While Malarkey shingles typically cost 10-15% more than entry-level asphalt shingles, reviews consistently indicate that customers find them to be a worthwhile investment. The extended lifespan and reduced maintenance requirements often offset the higher initial expenditure.

Homeowners who have compared lifecycle costs report that Malarkey roofs provide superior long-term value compared to less expensive alternatives that may require earlier replacement or more frequent repairs. Additionally, the potential insurance premium discounts available in some areas for impact-resistant shingles further enhance the overall value proposition.

Malarkey vs. Competitors

When compared directly with other major manufacturers like GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed, Malarkey frequently receives favorable reviews. Customers who have owned multiple roofs from different manufacturers often note Malarkey’s superior granule retention and color stability over time.

Contractors who work with multiple brands highlight Malarkey’s consistent manufacturing quality with fewer defects out of the package. While some reviews mention that certain competitors may offer more color options or marketing support, Malarkey consistently outperforms in the technical performance categories that determine long-term satisfaction.

Feature	Malarkey	Major Competitors
Impact Resistance	Excellent	Good to Excellent
Wind Resistance	Superior	Average to Good
Environmental Features	Industry Leading	Variable
Warranty Coverage	Comprehensive	Comparable

Installation Reviews and Contractor Feedback

Professional roofers generally give Malarkey shingles high marks for installation quality. The expanded nailing zone and clearly marked guidelines make proper installation more consistent, even with less experienced crews. This translates to fewer installation errors that could compromise roof performance.

Contractors also appreciate that Malarkey shingles typically experience less waste during installation due to better packaging and fewer damaged shingles per bundle. While some note that the heavier weight of certain Malarkey products can make handling more labor-intensive, they generally agree that the quality of the finished roof justifies any additional effort.